The not so innocents abroad
Reflections on modern pilgrimage to Israel
Andrew Siebert
ChristianWeek Staff
editor@christianweek.org
For Canadian Christians thinking of making a pilgrimage to the Holy Land, now is a better time than ever to do it. Counter-intuitive as it sounds, here’s why.
Israel’s important annual policy convention in
Herzliya highlighted one
important change in tone
since Sharon supported a
withdrawal from the West
Bank last year. Palestinian
Fatah leader Mahmoud
Abbas, King Abdullah of
Saudi Arabia, and Abdullah II of Jordan are now closer
allies than ever to the tiny democracy in the Levant—all
united against Iran.
But let’s not talk too much politics. A pilgrimage is a
search for the new and the perennially old, the physical trial of stark geography and the questions within. In
Jerusalem—a place that defies categorization—one finds
something new around every
corner. One comes less to
judge than to imbibe the
centuries through the smell
of the soil and to laugh and
discuss with real people in
all quarters.
Last month, I was fortunate enough to make
a whirlwind tour of the
country along with five
other Christian journalists.
I walked on 2,000 year-old pavement, sat in the
synagogue of the Zealots on
Masada, visited that “cursed”
town of Capernaum, ate St.
Peter’s fish from the Sea
of Galilee and entered the
empty garden tomb.
Sure enough, the garden
tomb matches the description in Mark of an angel sitting on the right hand side
as you walk in. In Luke, the
angels say “why do you look
for the living among the dead?” For many pilgrims, this is a
contradiction. They are looking for the way, the truth and
the life in a place that has been carved out of the rock by
a rich man.
What many find instead is a tourist paradise. Almost
always on a tight budget, pilgrimage means brushing
shoulders with tourism. Fortunately, Israel couldn’t be a
better place that. In a couple hours you can be skiing in Mt.
Hermon, trailblazing offroad, trekking up Masada, or scuba
diving in Eilat. For some, the fact Malta has outperformed
Israel three to one as a tourist destination in recent years
is very sad.
Did I mention the roads are also much better than
Winnipeg’s? Mark Twain cynical account of pilgrimage to
the Holy Land, The Innocents Abroad (1867), is frequently
quoted by Israelis hoping to compare the “mournful, and
dreary, and lifeless” landscape of the past to the amazing
modern developments of the present. It’s not hard to see.
A grove of date palms now grows beside the Dead Sea, and
Caesarea Maritima—the artificial port built by Herod the
Great—is just miles away from the “silicon valley” of the
Middle East.
Politics aside, the secular state of Israel is an envigo-
rating place to be. From the new Yad Vashem Holocaust
museum to the bustling nightlife along Ben Yehuda Street
in Jerusalem, one is never in want for something to explore.
And since the pope’s visit in 2000, countless shekels have
been spent developing historical sites.
Although security was high, I felt safe at all times.
I was also able to revisit the sight of Tel Rehov, an archae-
ological dig I volunteered on six years ago led my Amihai
Mazar. Now more than ever, exciting digs forge ahead—and
most are open to volunteers (see www.findadig.com). More
and more of the City of David is under excavation. The pool
of Siloam has been found, along with a staircase up to the
Temple Mount. Huge cisterns shed light on the mysteries
of Hezekiah’s tunnel.
As Condoleeza Rice gave a press conference in our hotel, I was wandering Old Jerusalem, navigating streets, swimming through crowds at prayer time and worshipping in Crusader-era churches. Near sundown on Shabbat, I sat at the Western Wall and encountered some young Argentine Jews who invited me to study the Torah. “What does it mean for Passover to have happened exactly at midnight?” We tackled the passage from all angles.
Our secular Zionist tour guide encouraged us to visit Palestinians and meet real people. Perhaps friendship—
the kind that is experienced between Israelis and Arabs every day—is a pre-requisite to peace. But for this, physical proximity is necessary. To understand, you must look into human faces.
It is in this proximity that one comes up against a kaleidescope of perspectives to sort out. Visiting the land is a drop
in the bucket of understanding. But visiting the land can also
give you a bucket to contextualize the study of Scripture.
As you walk along ancient stones, you cannot help but
think of the spirit of King Herod the Great—envy, greed,
jealousy, empire—it is very much alive today. His signature
stones can be seen lodged in the Western Wall and David’s
citadel. As a pilgrim, one cannont help but find the spirit
of King Herod within as well.
After a day’s wandering through the Old City of Jerusalem
you get back to your hotel and sit in front of a mirror watch-
ing the news. “Why do you look for the living among the
dead?” Visit Jerusalem, and see for yourself.